Delusional Leaders Are Dangerous Leaders

www.theamericanconservative.com

At time of writing, it looks like the U.S.-Iran ceasefire may be on its last legs. On Tuesday, the U.S. military launched strikes against more than 80 targets in Iran, retaliating for what the Pentagon termed Iran’s “unwarranted aggression” in firing on three commercial ships earlier in the week. President Trump, asked about the situation at the NATO summit in Ankara, called dealing with the Iranians “a waste of time” and pronounced the interim agreement signed last month “over.”

Even before the latest strikes, however, the president had been sounding a more bellicose note. In his Fourth of July speech, he invoked America’s “recent victory” in Iran, claiming that America “wiped out their military.” And when asked earlier this week about the prospects for a final agreement with Tehran, he doubled down, telling reporters “We’re either going to make a deal, or we’re going to finish the job. It won’t be tough to finish the job.”

Trump reminds one of a baseball team that, after losing 1–0, claims victory because it outhit its opponent—and demands a rematch. The lesson that the rest of the world has learned seems to have escaped him. Iran’s military and its infrastructure have indeed been pummeled, but Iran has not lost the war. 

Iran maintains the ability to operate most of the missile sites it uses to close the Strait and put American and allied targets at risk. It has restored access to 90 percent of its underground missile storage and launch facilities. It still has 75 percent of its mobile missile launchers, 70 percent of its ballistic and cruise missiles and 50 percent of its drones. The regime remains sturdily ensconced in Tehran, with little prospect of a popular uprising or an internal coup.

The United States has suffered far less damage—yet failed to accomplish its aims. And there have been costs. Thirteen American service members have been killed. Vast quantities of scarce and expensive (“exquisite,” as the Pentagon calls them) munitions have been expended, including Patriot and THAAD interceptors, Tomahawk and JASSM cruise missiles, and Precision Strike Missiles. Unprecedented damage has been inflicted upon American bases in the region, including the Bahrain headquarters of the U.S. Navy’s Fifth Fleet. At home, American consumers endured months of high gas prices and creeping inflation at home. Not to mention the political cost to the Trump administration of owning a war three in five Americans oppose.

Though pounded, Iran is in many ways stronger today than it was before the war. It has shown that it can survive the application of America’s two greatest sources of leverage: military superiority and economic pressure. And it has shown that the United States cannot stop it from applying leverage of its own. Today, Iran exercises more control over the Strait of Hormuz than ever before. Iran now has, at least temporarily, access to oil revenue and frozen assets (though this may be changing; earlier this week, the U.S. revoked the waiver allowing Iran to sell oil). And it has not yielded on its insistence on its right to a civilian enrichment program.

“Iran has clearly won the war and enjoys a significant advantage over the U.S. in the balance of coercive leverage,” John Mearsheimer, a professor of political science at the University of Chicago, told The American Conservative. “That is why President Trump signed the Memorandum of Understanding with Iran, even though it is effectively a surrender document."

The danger is that the White House doesn’t seem to realize this fact. And that could lead us back into the morass of an unwinnable war.

A similar delusion is prolonging the bloodletting in Ukraine. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and his European boosters are apparently convinced that the tide of the war has turned, and that a Ukrainian victory is not only possible but even imminent.

Delusion has, of course, characterized this war since its outset. Just as Zelensky was reportedly persuaded by European hawks to reject a peace deal in the spring of 2022, he is now listening to his European—and, recently, American—friends who tell him to continue the fight and force Russia to the negotiating table on his terms.

It is true that Ukrainian drone strikes represent a change in the conflict’s dynamics. The ability to hit the Russian heartland—from symbolic targets in St. Petersburg and Moscow to the petroleum refineries that keep Russia’s economy humming—is certainly having an impact. Indeed, Putin conceded as much in an interview last month (while also maintaining that they would “have no impact whatsoever on the situation at the front”).

But so far, Ukraine’s new reach does not seem to pose an existential threat to the Russian war machine. And Russian missile and drone attacks continue to deal more damage to Ukrainian cities and infrastructure than the reverse. 

Consider Russia’s most recent barrage, launched against Ukrainian cities earlier this week: according to the BBC, “Ukraine did not stop a single ballistic missile.” 

This has led to increasing desperation in Kiev. According to Putin, Zelensky even proposed that both sides agree to halt their long-range drone and missile exchanges.

And for all that these attacks have grabbed global headlines, the overall situation for Ukraine remains decidedly grim. As one expert at the Harvard Kennedy School observed late last month, Ukraine’s new drone strike capabilities “have not produced a decisive, durable shift in the overall direction or balance of the war.” Or, as another analyst wrote a few weeks earlier, “the drone war is a distraction.”

Subscribe Today Get daily emails in your inbox

The reason for this is simple: the conflict’s outcome will be determined by what happens on the Donbas front. And there, Russia continues to make slow but steady advances, and Ukraine looks ever more likely to lose a region it might well have kept under the Minsk accords.

In parts of the key stronghold of Konstantinovka, for example, depleted and exhausted Ukrainian units appear on the verge of collapse amid a relentless Russian assault. Ukraine’s manpower limitations are keenly felt, and the city’s fall seems only a matter of time. The tide, in other words, has not turned.

In both Ukraine and Iran, the delusions of leaders bent on winning the unwinnable threaten to create more misery and loss for all concerned. Both Zelensky and Trump should return to reality. Otherwise, the countries they lead face the prospect of yet more fruitless, endless war.