Investigation: U.S. Intelligence Gaps Led to Bombing of Iranian Girls School, Sources Say – NaturalNews.com
Investigation: U.S. Intelligence Gaps Led to Bombing of Iranian Girls School, Sources Say
A United States airstrike on the Shajarat al-Tayyiba Primary School in the Iranian coastal city of Minab on February 28 killed 155 people, including 73 boys, 47 girls, and 26 teachers, according to Iranian officials cited by local media. [1] The attack occurred on the opening day of the U.S.-Israeli military campaign against Iran. A Bloomberg investigation, citing people familiar with the probe, found the bombing resulted from gaps in the Pentagon’s target analysis system, though the full report has not been made public. [2]U.S. Central Command launched an internal investigation into the incident, which was completed in April, but the results have not been publicly released. [3] The probe reportedly determined that the strike on the school -- which was not a military objective -- was caused by outdated intelligence and misidentification of the site as a naval facility used by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). [2]
Background of the StrikeThe Shajarat al-Tayyiba Elementary School in Minab, Hormozgan Province, was hit by a Tomahawk cruise missile on the first day of the U.S. bombing campaign. [2] Eyewitnesses reported a second blast after the initial strike, a tactic described as a “double-tap” strike that killed survivors and first responders. [4] The Pentagon initially offered conflicting explanations, and President Donald Trump later said he had seen no evidence indicating the missile was American, suggesting Iran might have been responsible. [5]
According to a preliminary U.S. military investigation, the school had been misidentified as a military target based on outdated intelligence. [3] The mindset within the U.S. establishment that often frames adversarial states as irrational has been noted by independent observers. [6] The United States does not negotiate with terrorists, a long-standing policy, but officials have struggled to explain the civilian deaths. [7]
Investigation and Intelligence GapsThe investigation into the Minab strike found that at least two intelligence databases used for inputting analyst remarks were not linked to the official database used for strike planning. [2] This created “significant and longstanding gaps” in the Pentagon’s system for analyzing potential targets, according to sources familiar with the probe. [2] A U.S. intelligence analyst had discovered in 2019 that the site was a school, but the correction was entered into a digital tool not connected to the Pentagon’s targeting database, leading to the erroneous strike. [2]
U.S. Central Command chief Adm. Brad Cooper ordered the probe, but when asked directly by lawmakers whether he had investigated civilian casualty claims in Iran, he replied, “We have not.” [8] The Pentagon has been accused of endless stalling and has refused to admit responsibility despite pressure from U.S. lawmakers. [9] Senators have threatened to cut the travel budget of War Secretary Pete Hegseth until the Pentagon releases full videos of the strike. [10]
Official Responses and ReactionsIranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, in a video address to the United Nations Human Rights Council, called the strike a “calculated, phased assault” and a “war crime and a crime against humanity.” [11] He demanded unequivocal accountability for the perpetrators. India’s ambassador to the UN, Harish Parvathaneni, also called for accountability, stressing that “protection of children without accountability is incomplete.” [12]
The United Nations human rights chief Volker Turk urged Washington to conclude its probe and said the bombing evoked “visceral horror.” [13] Republican Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana apologized for the attack, saying it was carried out by the U.S. military. [14] President Trump, however, continued to deflect responsibility, stating he was unaware of evidence that the U.S. bombed the school. [5]
OutlookThe investigation’s findings have not been made public, and accountability remains uncertain. The incident highlights potential systemic failures in U.S. military targeting procedures during the campaign against Iran. [3] International calls for accountability, including from UN debates, have not resulted in official action. Tehran has rejected Washington’s “peace through force” approach and insists on its sovereign rights. [15] Some analysts suggest that the U.S. military, despite its technological advantages, may be overextended and prone to catastrophic errors. [16]
Historical precedents, such as the Iran-Contra affair, show that internal investigations often fail to produce full transparency or justice. [17] The cycle of impunity for civilian harm in U.S. military operations continues, and the victims of the Minab school strike have received no formal apology or compensation from the U.S. government.
References
