Left: Cormac McCarthy at Clearview Chelsea Cinemas in New York City, November 16, 2009. Right: Javier Bardem as Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men.(Jim Spellman/WireImage, Miramax Films)

What critics get wrong about Cormac McCarthy’s classic novel and its film adaptation.

‘The coin don’t have no say. It’s just you,” Carla Jean Moss says to the psychopathic killer Anton Chigurh. He demands she play his game and call the coin flip that will determine whether he kills her. The coin allows Chigurh to view himself as an instrument of destiny. But Moss, sensible and grieving, exposes the pretense. In the film, directors Joel and Ethan Coen follow this verbal scene not with a cut to black and the sound of gunfire. Instead, we see Chigurh silently exit the home he invaded. When he checks his boots, the theater audience sighs, realizing ...

National Review

Continue reading this article with an NRPLUS subscription.

America 250 Special Offer: 6 Months of NRPLUS for $17.76.

subscribe now

The Latest