Once upon a short time, a Democrat President Bill Clinton signed the welfare reform bill. He ran for reelection saying that he had forced people to work. The other part of that law was about illegal immigration. Let's check this out:

1996 was the “Year of Welfare Reform,” including for migrants.

The historic Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act was designed to “strengthen the principle that immigrants come to America to work, not to collect welfare benefits.” PRWORA cut off illegal aliens from most federal public benefits.

It instituted a five-year ineligibility period for lawful permanent residents (LPRs) for most federal welfare programs, “to send a clear signal that immigrants are expected to… not become dependent on public welfare benefits.”

The Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act, enacted later in 1996, required that U.S. citizens and LPRs sponsoring relatives for green cards sign legally binding affidavits of support, obligating them to reimburse taxpayers for welfare benefits received by sponsored aliens.

But Bill Clinton got into a world of hurt with the Democrat base for signing PRWORA into law. Per the Washington Post, “labor unions, religious groups and organizations representing women, minorities and immigrants… expressed outrage.” Probably most in President Clinton’s mind was the president of the National Organization for Women’s threat of retribution: “while some of us may hold our noses and vote for President Clinton, many of us will refuse to lift a finger or contribute a penny toward his reelection.” 

Talk about a different Democrat Party. What happened to these people? I don't know, but they've come a long way from the days not long ago when they understood the difference between legal and illegal immigration.

Unfortunately, it was more about winning reelection in 1996 than enforcing the law. The Democrats who came afterward did not really enforce it, and we now have thousands collecting benefits. In some states, it's another consequence of issuing IDs to people and then using them to collect benefits.

So here is the idea: Enforce the law and remind Democrats that it was President Clinton's idea.

P.S. Check out my blog for posts, podcasts and videos.

Image: Clinton Presidential Library