Corporate America stands at a crossroads. One path leads toward the preservation of free enterprise through open competition, equal treatment under the law, and the relentless pursuit of innovation. The other leads toward an increasingly politicized economy where success depends less upon satisfying customers than upon cultivating politicians, regulators, and bureaucrats. The tragedy is that many corporations have mistaken the second path for the easier one. In doing so, they may be laying the groundwork for their own destruction.

Advertisement

Nothing has done more to discredit capitalism than cronyism masquerading as free enterprise. This perverse vision of capitalism is at the core of why it is being roundly rejected by young Americans.

When government grants subsidies to favored industries, protects entrenched corporations from competition, distributes taxpayer-funded bailouts, erects regulatory barriers that only large firms can afford, or awards politically connected companies lucrative contracts unavailable to others, the public correctly recognizes that the system is rigged. Unfortunately, they often blame the wrong culprit.

Advertisement

The villain is not capitalism. The villain is the abandonment of capitalism for political favoritism. While true capitalism rewards businesses that best serve consumers, cronyism rewards businesses that best serve politicians.

Corporate executives have been empowered through the political system to make Faustian bargains with government. They lobby for subsidies, tax preferences, regulatory exemptions, or protective tariffs that strengthen their competitive position. But those favors carried a hidden cost. Each special privilege weakens public confidence when success is obtained through political influence rather than merit.

Advertisement

When ordinary Americans watch politically connected corporations receive billions in subsidies while small businesses struggle under mountains of regulations, they frequently conclude that capitalism itself is corrupt.

That misconception creates fertile ground for socialism.

Advertisement

Socialists rarely attack free markets as they actually exist. Instead, they point toward politically connected corporations, government bailouts, concentrated economic power, and favoritism. Cronyism hands socialism its most effective campaign advertisements.

Every bailout becomes another talking point. Every politically connected contract becomes another recruiting poster. Every regulatory action protecting established firms becomes another argument that markets only benefit the wealthy.

Advertisement

Corporate America would be wise to recognize that these short-term political victories will produce a long-term ideological defeat. History offers repeated warnings of this.

Once the government establishes the principle that it may direct investment, allocate resources, determine winners and losers, or intervene whenever politically advantageous, corporations become increasingly dependent upon remaining in political favor. Their independence steadily disappears. They fail to understand that the hand that feeds them will eventually become the hand that controls them.

Advertisement

Executives who cheer government intervention when it benefits them should not be surprised when later administrations use that same authority to impose mandates they dislike, dictate corporate behavior, pressure hiring decisions, influence product offerings, or redirect capital toward politically preferred objectives.

Power rarely remains confined to its original purpose. It expands.

The only durable protection for business is not friendly politicians. It is limited government. Corporate leaders should therefore become the strongest defenders of equal treatment under the law.

Imagine a business community that collectively rejected targeted subsidies, opposed industry-specific bailouts, demanded lower barriers to entry rather than regulations that shield incumbents, insisted tax policy apply equally instead of rewarding political influence, and welcomed competition instead of lobbying against it.

Such positions might reduce quarterly profits for a handful of politically connected firms, but they would dramatically strengthen public confidence in the legitimacy of markets.

Consumers do not resent wealth honestly earned. They resent wealth that is politically manufactured. It is no wonder that young people resent a rigged system that limits opportunity to reward corporate fat cats. Socialism is promoted as a logical alternative. True capitalism -- the system that built our nation and attracts immigrants like no other country -- is left out of the discussion.

The marketplace rewards service. Cronyism rewards access. One builds trust. The other destroys it.

Some executives assume they can navigate this political landscape indefinitely by supporting whichever party currently holds power. But history suggests otherwise. Political coalitions evolve. Public sentiment shifts. New movements emerge. Companies that tether themselves to government privilege eventually discover that privileges can be revoked just as easily as they were granted.

Meanwhile, public hostility toward business continues to grow. This should alarm every boardroom in America. The greatest long-term threat to American capitalism is not vigorous competition. It is the government having its thumb on the scale.

Cronyism blurs the line between capitalism and socialism until citizens lose sight of what genuine economic freedom actually looks like.

Corporate America can help restore that distinction. The most powerful defense of capitalism is not another advertising campaign celebrating free enterprise. It is demonstrating that businesses are willing to compete without special favors.

Reject the subsidy. Reject the bailout. Reject regulations designed to handicap smaller rivals. Reject political favoritism regardless of which party offers it.

Compete on quality. Compete on price. Compete on innovation. Compete on service.

Those principles built the greatest engine of prosperity in human history and can preserve the moral legitimacy upon which free enterprise ultimately depends.

Corporate America should understand that every act of cronyism purchases temporary protection at the expense of capitalism’s future. Such a bargain may enrich today’s shareholders, but it steadily convinces tomorrow’s voters that markets cannot be trusted. That is a catastrophic trade.

Businesses that truly believe in capitalism should be its first line of defense -- not merely against socialism, but against the political favoritism that makes socialism appear attractive in the first place. The choice is remarkably simple. Defend free markets while they still command public confidence. Or continue defending cronyism until the public decides to abandon both.

Jim Cardoza is the author of The Moral Superiority of Liberty and the founder of LibertyPen.com. Read more of his essays there.