'I Don’t Know If I Feel Right Putting A Brother In Jail': Prosecutors Dismiss Black Jurors For Karmelo Anthony Trial
Prosecutors dismissed all black jurors from Karmelo Anthony’s murder trial, CBS News reported Wednesday.
Prosecutors and defense attorneys narrowed a pool of 589 prospective jurors to 12 jurors and six alternates, according to CBS News. Jury selection for the trial began on June 1 in Collin County, Texas, WFAA reported. During jury selection questioning, potential jurors were asked whether Anthony’s age would influence their decision to render a verdict.
“He looks like a child. I can’t send him to jail. He could learn from his mistake,” one person said, according to the outlet.
“Seeing someone who looks like a kid — I can’t determine [a] verdict,” another stated.
“I don’t know if I feel right putting a brother in jail,” one other potential juror admitted, bringing up race.
Potential Karmelo Anthony jurors dismissed after saying they could never send him to prison: ‘He looks like a child’ https://t.co/E1D7QUOaw4 pic.twitter.com/44mFxOjBUi
— New York Post (@nypost) June 3, 2026
In addition to Anthony’s age and race, another potential juror cited their religious views, according to WFAA.
“It would violate my religious views to punish someone,” the potential juror said. (RELATED: REPORT: Karmelo Anthony Allowed To Graduate While Charged With Murder)
Anthony has been charged with first-degree murder after he allegedly stabbed Austin Metcalf in April 2025. Anthony claimed Metcalf “put his hands” on him during a fight at a track meet, according to FOX 4. Metcalf died as a result of the incident.
Witnesses claim Anthony, a then 17-year-old student at Centennial High School, was sitting under the Memorial High School tent at the track meet and was instructed to leave. One witness claimed that Metcalf, a student at Memorial High School, pushed Anthony to get him to leave the tent before Anthony allegedly pulled out a knife and stabbed Metcalf in the chest, FOX 4 reported. Anthony asked what would happen if he said he acted in self-defense, according to a police report.
Collin County Judge John Roach, Jr. issued a gag order on Anthony’s case in July 2025.
The trial is expected to last two weeks, according to WFAA.