Is Trump a Lame Duck Yet? - The American Prospect
At several points in the past few months, it looked as if Trump had gone too far and that resistance to his incipient dictatorship had reached a turning point. But each time, it didn’t quite happen.
In mid-September, I wrote a moderately optimistic piece for the Prospect, taking stock of the various elements of resistance, most notably courts and elections. Many readers felt I was being a little too hopeful.
Since Election Day, however, there has been a notable shift. And each aspect feeds on the others. They include:
Trump kept pressuring House Republicans not to sign the discharge petition to force the Justice Department to release the Epstein files. He threatened to punish Republicans who resisted, but in the end it was Trump who was thoroughly humiliated.
@media ( min-width: 300px ){.newspack_global_ad.scaip-2{min-height: 100px;}}@media ( min-width: 728px ){.newspack_global_ad.scaip-2{min-height: 90px;}}The White House, by trying to delay release of the files by launching a whole new investigation, is miscalculating again. This only keeps Epstein in the headlines: What is Trump hiding?
But the Republicans’ Epstein revolt is only the beginning. Republican legislators have defied Trump’s demand to end the filibuster, his scheme to engage the cost-of-living issue by sending everyone a $2,000 “tariff rebate” check, his proposal for a $10,000 subsidy for people to buy private health insurance, his idea for 50-year mortgages, and more. They are not taking him seriously.
Republicans have joined Democrats in expressing unease about his illegal demolition of fishing boats as alleged drug smugglers, his plan for a splendid little war on Venezuela, and his latest pro-Putin scheme to sell out Ukraine.
His threats to primary disloyal Republicans are going nowhere. And the more Republicans are willing to stand up to him, the more his threats ring hollow.
There is also the sheer incompetence of Trump’s efforts to use selective prosecutions to punish political opponents. Trump’s effort to prosecute former FBI director James Comey has turned into an embarrassing fiasco. The Department of Justice admitted that it never presented the two-count indictment to the full grand jury.
@media ( min-width: 300px ){.newspack_global_ad.scaip-3{min-height: 100px;}}@media ( min-width: 728px ){.newspack_global_ad.scaip-3{min-height: 90px;}}The appalled magistrate wrote, “If this procedure did not take place, then the court is in uncharted legal territory in that the indictment returned in open court was not the same charging document presented to and deliberated upon by the grand jury.” The whole case may be thrown out.
The Prospect in your inboxSubscribe for analysis that goes beyond the noise.
And Trump’s crony, Federal Housing Finance Agency Director Bill Pulte, who has combed mortgage records to find ways to prosecute prominent Democrats, is now on the defensive himself, as lawyers challenge his flagrant conflicts of interest. Trump’s minions even managed to bungle a slam dunk by admitting the sheer racism in the Texas redistricting plan, which was then overruled by a three-judge panel, with the most indignant comments coming from a Trump appointee.
Appellate Judge Jeffrey Brown wrote that “it’s challenging to unpack the DOJ Letter because it contains so many factual, legal, and typographical errors. Indeed, even attorneys employed by the Texas Attorney General—who professes to be a political ally of the Trump Administration—describe the DOJ Letter as ‘legally[] unsound,’ ‘baseless,’ ‘erroneous,’ ‘ham-fisted,’ and ‘a mess.’”
Meanwhile, the Republican victory in forcing Democrats to reopen the government with no concessions on health care is looking more and more like a defeat because it keeps the issue of unaffordable health insurance front and center. In the most recent polls, approval of Trump is underwater by 17 points. Even among Republicans, his approval is 68 percent, sharply down from 92 percent in March. As we head into an election year, with Democrats flipping both Houses a distinct possibility, more and more Republican legislators are looking to save their own skins—which gives them more reason to distance themselves from Trump, and the process keeps intensifying.
So are we out of the woods yet? No, we are not.
The more Trump is on the defensive, the more hysterical he becomes. The latest example is his call to execute Democrats who pointed out that the professional military has an obligation to defy illegal commands. Even the White House press office had to walk that back. But Trump is continuing to use carrots and sticks with the corporate parents of media organizations to destroy a free and critical press.
And as an increasingly desperate Trump tries to keep changing the subject and the headlines, watch out for even more reckless foreign-policy adventures.
However, something fundamental has shifted. Trump is not a dead duck yet, but he is increasingly a lame one. And the more he proves impotent to punish defiant Republicans, the more they will keep acting to distance themselves and to weaken Trump.
We may yet redeem our democracy. That seemed a long shot just a few months ago. Not a bad cause for Thanksgiving.
First, I want to thank you for reading the Prospect. At the end of the day, you’re helping build a more just and fair world by taking the time to read independent and fearless journalism. We hope that when you read our work it isn’t just idle entertainment or cynical ragebait, but something that informs and inspires you. If you agree with that, and I hope you do, we’re asking that you take the next step and consider supporting our work. We don’t have corporate sponsors or billionaire backers – we have you, our readers. A significant portion of the money it takes to send reporters into the field to write the hard-hitting stories you expect from the Prospect comes from readers just like you. Can you chip in today? Your support funds deeply reported investigations into power, how it works, and what it means for you.
Mitchell Grummon
Publisher